The “Public Option” Is Not Dead
Wednesday, September 30th, 2009 by RLRFrom TruthOut
By Scott Galindez
I would not be honest if I said the “public option” is alive and well. It is clearly in critical condition, but all hope is not lost. There is still significant support in the House for a strong “public option.” In the Senate there appears to be 51 votes for a weaker “public option” like the one presented on Tuesday by Sen. Chuck Schumer (D-New York). The problem is 60 votes are needed in the Senate without utilizing what is known as the reconciliation option.
It is now more than likely that the bill that will go to the floor of the Senate will not have a “public plan” in it. When the bill gets to the Senate, there will be another chance to amend it. Adding an amendment that will not prevent the bill from getting the 60 votes needed will not be easy, but it’s not impossible.
The Sixty Votes
I agree with the critics that say there will not be 60 votes for a public option. What if the 60 members of the Democratic caucus committed to at least voting to end debate and then voted the way they wanted on final passage? I think the “public option” would have 51 votes, possibly more. Even 50 would be enough with Vice President Biden casting the tiebreaker.
I believe all Democrats should vote for a public option, but I know that the Blue Dogs like Blanche Lincoln and Mary Landrieu will not. Let them do something for party unity and vote to end closure before selling out to corporate interests. It probably won’t happen, but it is worth fighting for.
You might be wondering why I didn’t mention Max Baucus or Kent Conrad. Well, I think they would vote for cloture and would vote for the public option if they thought it would make it through the Senate.
Read more Healthcare
Cloture is not going to happen for at least one basic reason. By now, too many deals have already been made by legislators, e.g., the 80 billion limit on the contribution that will be made by Big Pharma to health care reform. What’s left are adjustments on the margins, and the public option is not a marginal matter.